I know I've said my piece before about brunch, and I am still not the biggest fan of brunching (I just don't see why people want to pay $10+ for bacon/eggs/potatoes/french toast that you could make in your own kitchen at home?), but we all know that about 90% of social activities revolve around either food or drinks. Since I don't really drink alcohol, I can't also turn down invitations to food-related activities without becoming a hermit, so yes, I occasionally go to brunch.
The other weekend, my upstairs neighbors T. and V., asked us if I wanted to go out to the city for a brunch date. V. has had Feast on her places to try for a while, so we decided to eat there. We made a reservation at the last minute (as in, Sunday morning at 11am) and managed to secure a table at 1:30pm for a party of 4.
The restaurant has a Pinterest "rustic chic" feel. The decor includes large farmhouse style wooden tables with tall stools, metal flower boxes with "country" flower arrangements (the long stemmed whispery plants that look like you could pick them from a field), empty picture frames on the walls, mounted deer head, and of course, mason jars.
Brunch prix fixe is $29pp for a drink, shared bites, and a main dish.
Overall, it was an above average meal, though I do think that the service could be improved.
The drinks offered include a mimosa, a bellini, a "beery mary", oj, or bottomless drip coffee. The orange juice is served in a teeny tiny glass, less than 8oz, and you don't get refills, which I honestly thought was kind of a rip off. How is bottomless coffee or an alcoholic drink equivalent to one small glass of OJ? I wish the OJ had been bottomless.
Since it was hot out, we asked for iced coffee, which the waitress said could be an alternative to the drip coffee (which is hot). Our iced coffees were served in mason jars that were about 60% ice. In the middle of our meal, when my friend and I asked for refills we were told that since the coffee is cold brew, refills are $5. Excuse me? That was not what I understood from the word "alternative." We were a little upset that our waitress had failed to mention that before. Also, if the coffee is cold brew, why are you serving it with so much ice? It just seemed like they were really cutting corners to maximize their profits.
The shared bites are listed as a "bakery basket", yogurt parfait, juice shot, and canape. The bakery basket was smaller than I imagined it would be, especially since it wasn't at all a basket. There were two tiny slices of a baked goods per person (changes daily). We got a sliver of a cinnamon bun and a tiny slice of carrot cake/bread. The cinnamon bun was soft and sweet, but nothing special. It actually tasted like something from a pre-made break-and-bake Pillsbury package. The carrot cake was also moist and sweet, but again, it was nothing extraordinary. The yogurt parfait was a shot glass of plain yogurt with granola and some diced pears; there was little flavor to the components so this was not particularly good. The juice shot was cantaloupe and was refreshing. The canape was bread with ricotta and truffle honey; it was the best part of the "bites."
For the main course, I tried the smoked salmon with red flannel hash and quail eggs. This was good. The salmon was fresh, well seasoned, and went well with the hash. I also really like the quail eggs. The runny yolks were sweeter than regular egg yolks, and the combination of flavors was good. It was a lot to eat though, and I wasn't able to finish my dish.
N. (V's sister, who tagged along) tried the banana foster french toast. The french toast was light and eggy, and the bananas and chocolate are a classic combination that works well. She enjoyed this, although after eating about half of it, the overwhelming sweetness of the dish was too much for her, and she could eat no more. We all tried it and agreed that while the flavors were good, the plate would have benefited from a salty or savory touch.
T. and V. both ordered the fennel sausage eggs benedict. The sausage in this dish was *incredible*. We were all in love with it. I don't know what combination of spices were use, but we all called it "pho sausage" because it reminded us of the flavors of the Vietnamese beef soup (and two of us in the group are actually Vietnamese). The poached eggs were perfectly cooked with runny yolks and set whites. This was everyone's favorite dish, although we all agreed that after a while, the dish felt very heavy. I think it would have benefited from a salad, or a touch of freshness or acidity. The steamed spinach didn't do much to cut the fat and provided no textural element, which would have been appreciated.
As for the service, we felt a little harried during our meal. Our waitress kept swooping in to take away plates, sometimes before we were done with our food. I felt like I had to constantly keep my guard up, because if it looked like I wasn't actively eating, she might step in and clear my plate. At one point, she picked up my "shared bites" plate and I had to beg her to wait a moment before she whisked it away so that I could grab my cinnamon bun. This also meant that as members of our group finished eating, she would come and take away plates, even if other people were still working on their meal. It was very intrusive and made us feel like we were being rushed to finish. This didn't really make sense, since we didn't get our food until almost 2pm, and there were no people waiting for tables. Furthermore, after we were done eating and the table had been cleared, our waitress disappeared and we could not find her for water refills or to get the check. We ended up sitting at the table for about 30 minutes before we were able to pay the bill and leave. Though we had enjoyed our food, the experience of our meal was a little marred by the service, which left something to be desired.
Feast
102 3rd Ave
New York, NY 10003
Tel. 212-529-8880
Brunch served Sat & Sun 11am-3pm
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Showing posts with label review. Show all posts
Tuesday, June 9, 2015
Sunday, April 12, 2015
Tasty n Alder Brunch in Portland
One of the most interesting things I read when I was researching restaurants is that Portland is apparently "the city for brunch." Living near New York City, I always thought that brunch was a NYC thing, but a New York brunch tends to be overpriced and much more focused on alcohol than I'd like (endless mimosas aren't such a good deal when you only drink one glass). I like Portland's brunch style much more.
My friend G. - who, by my standards, is a Portland expert, given her three years living there - suggested that we eat at Tasty n Alder. When I checked her suggestion on Yelp (because, let's be honest, I trust my friends, but I'm also a little bit of a Yelp fiend), it was strongly back by positive reviews, and she's been living here for three years, so I saw no reason not to go.
It was Easter Sunday the day we decided to eat here, so G gamely went to the restaurant first to put our names on the list while I stayed at her apartment getting ready (I have to look my finest while I third-wheel my dear friends, right?).
Our group of 3 (G, her fiance D, and myself) were added to the list at around 12:30ish. We were told the wait would be about one hour. We ended up killing some time at the coffeeshop across the street, where we all got our morning dose of caffeine. We got a text that our table was ready a little after 1:30pm. Having not eaten yet all morning, I was ready to dig into some food!
We ordered the Cast Iron Frittata, the Fried Egg and Cheddar Biscuit with fried chicken, the Bim Bop Bacon and Eggs, and the Whole Toad.
I was hoping for some table snacks while we waited... free muffins? free bread? my stomach was growling. But alas, nothing. However, the wait wasn't too long.
The Fried Egg and Cheddar Biscuit was the first dish to arrive. For any non-cheese eaters like myself, this dish can easily be made without cheese, since they just put a slice of cheddar on the biscuit. Unfortunately, I didn't realize this at the time (the name of the dish is kind of misleading), so I didn't eat any of the dish. My friends seems to enjoy it though. The chicken is a thin breaded breast. The egg had a nice runny yolk, and the biscuit came out steaming hot. Also, my apologies, but we were all so hungry when the dish arrived, I forgot to take a picture.
Next, came the Cast Iron Frittata (pictured above). This had nettles, roasted asparagus, caramelized onions, and salsa verde. The combination was stellar. We requested the cheese on the side (I believe it's supposed to be fontina), and it came in a cute little ceramic bowl so that my cheese-loving friends were able to sprinkle their frittata with as much cheese as they desired. The frittata had great texture. It was fluffy, absolutely delicious, and very satisfying. This was actually my favorite dish of the meal.
Then we had the Bim Bop Bacon and Eggs. This come out in a hot stone bowl (like the Korean dish bibimbap). Everything is stirred up, so you get soft bacon, runny eggs, and crispy rice all mixed up. So tasty. Also very filling. It's bigger than it looks! This dish almost, almost beat the Cast Iron Frittata on the delicious-ness scale, but I'm not a big fan of spicy kimchi, which was almost mixed in with the rice. I will say that the soft cooked bacon was a discovery. I normally am a thick-cut crispy bacon girl, but this dish definitely warmed me up to soft bacon. It wasn't gooey, and it was definitely cooked, but it was... moist? That's a terrible word to use to convey something delicious, but what I want you to understand is that it was very enjoyable.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/24c09/24c09d3b2bcf8ea0e623b65ebf9f912a3c68110f" alt=""
Finally, the last dish to come to the table was The Whole Toad. This is a baked egg bread pudding, which comes with even more bread. Carbs on carbs. No problemo. Except... is there cheese in this bread pudding? I don't know, but I wasn't particularly fond of this dish. There was a slight sourness or tartness to the egg pudding, and the ratio of eggs to bread leaned more heavily on the latter, while I had been hoping it would be the other way around (more eggs than bread).
As a drink, I ordered The Driver's Seat which is a non-alcoholic drink with earl grey syrup, mint, and lime juice. Sadly I didn't get any hints of earl grey, as the lime was very overpowering. But the drink was refreshing and did go well with brunch. My friends both ordered orange juice, which is freshly squeezed, but comes in a tiny glass (maybe 6oz?), so it's a little overpriced.
We considered ordering a sweet dish, but after these four plates came out, we were so stuffed, we called it quits. Next time though, that Griddled Banana Walnut Bread will be mine! The table next to us ordered it and it looked and smelled delicious.
Over all, we had great service in a very comfortable environment. I'd happily come back again.
Tasty n Alder
580 SW 12th Ave
Portland, OR 97205
![]() |
The Cast Iron Frittata |
My friend G. - who, by my standards, is a Portland expert, given her three years living there - suggested that we eat at Tasty n Alder. When I checked her suggestion on Yelp (because, let's be honest, I trust my friends, but I'm also a little bit of a Yelp fiend), it was strongly back by positive reviews, and she's been living here for three years, so I saw no reason not to go.
It was Easter Sunday the day we decided to eat here, so G gamely went to the restaurant first to put our names on the list while I stayed at her apartment getting ready (I have to look my finest while I third-wheel my dear friends, right?).
Our group of 3 (G, her fiance D, and myself) were added to the list at around 12:30ish. We were told the wait would be about one hour. We ended up killing some time at the coffeeshop across the street, where we all got our morning dose of caffeine. We got a text that our table was ready a little after 1:30pm. Having not eaten yet all morning, I was ready to dig into some food!
We ordered the Cast Iron Frittata, the Fried Egg and Cheddar Biscuit with fried chicken, the Bim Bop Bacon and Eggs, and the Whole Toad.
I was hoping for some table snacks while we waited... free muffins? free bread? my stomach was growling. But alas, nothing. However, the wait wasn't too long.
The Fried Egg and Cheddar Biscuit was the first dish to arrive. For any non-cheese eaters like myself, this dish can easily be made without cheese, since they just put a slice of cheddar on the biscuit. Unfortunately, I didn't realize this at the time (the name of the dish is kind of misleading), so I didn't eat any of the dish. My friends seems to enjoy it though. The chicken is a thin breaded breast. The egg had a nice runny yolk, and the biscuit came out steaming hot. Also, my apologies, but we were all so hungry when the dish arrived, I forgot to take a picture.
![]() |
Bim Bop Bacon and Eggs |
Then we had the Bim Bop Bacon and Eggs. This come out in a hot stone bowl (like the Korean dish bibimbap). Everything is stirred up, so you get soft bacon, runny eggs, and crispy rice all mixed up. So tasty. Also very filling. It's bigger than it looks! This dish almost, almost beat the Cast Iron Frittata on the delicious-ness scale, but I'm not a big fan of spicy kimchi, which was almost mixed in with the rice. I will say that the soft cooked bacon was a discovery. I normally am a thick-cut crispy bacon girl, but this dish definitely warmed me up to soft bacon. It wasn't gooey, and it was definitely cooked, but it was... moist? That's a terrible word to use to convey something delicious, but what I want you to understand is that it was very enjoyable.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/24c09/24c09d3b2bcf8ea0e623b65ebf9f912a3c68110f" alt=""
Finally, the last dish to come to the table was The Whole Toad. This is a baked egg bread pudding, which comes with even more bread. Carbs on carbs. No problemo. Except... is there cheese in this bread pudding? I don't know, but I wasn't particularly fond of this dish. There was a slight sourness or tartness to the egg pudding, and the ratio of eggs to bread leaned more heavily on the latter, while I had been hoping it would be the other way around (more eggs than bread).
As a drink, I ordered The Driver's Seat which is a non-alcoholic drink with earl grey syrup, mint, and lime juice. Sadly I didn't get any hints of earl grey, as the lime was very overpowering. But the drink was refreshing and did go well with brunch. My friends both ordered orange juice, which is freshly squeezed, but comes in a tiny glass (maybe 6oz?), so it's a little overpriced.
We considered ordering a sweet dish, but after these four plates came out, we were so stuffed, we called it quits. Next time though, that Griddled Banana Walnut Bread will be mine! The table next to us ordered it and it looked and smelled delicious.
Over all, we had great service in a very comfortable environment. I'd happily come back again.
Tasty n Alder
580 SW 12th Ave
Portland, OR 97205
Sunday, April 5, 2015
Ken's Artisan Bakery and Portland
If there's anything you surely must know about me, it's that I am a dessert person. Above all else (except, maybe, sleep), I love sweets.
So when I started looking up places to eat in Portland and I heard about Ken's Artisan Bakery and the croissants, macarons, and other pastries that come out of their ovens, I knew that I had to go.
In fact, on my first day in Portland, this was the first place I went to start my morning. It was a great decision. Friendly service, yummy pastries, good food, and reasonable prices. I had no complaints!
I walked in at around 10ish on a Friday morning, and many of the tables were taken. I took that as a good sign. I lingered near the cash register for a while, debating what to drink and what goodies to try. I apologized for not being able to make up my mind, but the man behind the counter was really patient with me. I ended up ordering an Oregon croissant, a blood orange macaron, and a cafe latte (as per the suggestion of the man behind the counter).
I settled down at one of the empty tables I managed to snag to enjoy my breakfast. The coffee wasn't that strong and wasn't that hot, so I didn't really enjoy it much, but that might also be because lattes aren't normally my thing and this place obviously isn't a coffeeshop. On to the sweet stuff!
The Oregon croissant has marionberries baked into the flakey pastry, and its flecked with sugar crystals, which add a nice combination of soft tartness and sweet crunch. I polished this off quickly, and I liked it so much, I ended up coming back to the bakery before I left the city to buy two more to keep me company on my travels home. The croissant is the perfect breakfast since it isn't too sweet.
The blood orange macaron I ordered was also delicious. The candied kumquat on top added a perfect little bit of acidity to offset the sweetness, and the texture of both the macaron itself and the filling were perfect.
I also decided to eat lunch here with my friend G, who lives in the city. We both went with their lunch deal, which is either a half soup or half salad with a half sandwich combo. G. went with salad and sandwich while I went with soup and sandwich. For a mere $8, I had an egg salad sandwich and white bean soup. Both were delicious. The soup was warm, hearty, and perfectly seasoned. It was great for a drizzly day. The egg salad sandwich was well balanced - egg wasn't chopped too small, there wasn't an overwhelming amount of mayo, and there was just a slight bite from the mustard. The bread they used was sturdy but not heavy, and I liked their plating with the edible violet.
If I lived in the area, I think this would be my go-to spot for sweets and lazy day lunches.
So when I started looking up places to eat in Portland and I heard about Ken's Artisan Bakery and the croissants, macarons, and other pastries that come out of their ovens, I knew that I had to go.
In fact, on my first day in Portland, this was the first place I went to start my morning. It was a great decision. Friendly service, yummy pastries, good food, and reasonable prices. I had no complaints!
I walked in at around 10ish on a Friday morning, and many of the tables were taken. I took that as a good sign. I lingered near the cash register for a while, debating what to drink and what goodies to try. I apologized for not being able to make up my mind, but the man behind the counter was really patient with me. I ended up ordering an Oregon croissant, a blood orange macaron, and a cafe latte (as per the suggestion of the man behind the counter).
I settled down at one of the empty tables I managed to snag to enjoy my breakfast. The coffee wasn't that strong and wasn't that hot, so I didn't really enjoy it much, but that might also be because lattes aren't normally my thing and this place obviously isn't a coffeeshop. On to the sweet stuff!
The Oregon croissant has marionberries baked into the flakey pastry, and its flecked with sugar crystals, which add a nice combination of soft tartness and sweet crunch. I polished this off quickly, and I liked it so much, I ended up coming back to the bakery before I left the city to buy two more to keep me company on my travels home. The croissant is the perfect breakfast since it isn't too sweet.
The blood orange macaron I ordered was also delicious. The candied kumquat on top added a perfect little bit of acidity to offset the sweetness, and the texture of both the macaron itself and the filling were perfect.
I also decided to eat lunch here with my friend G, who lives in the city. We both went with their lunch deal, which is either a half soup or half salad with a half sandwich combo. G. went with salad and sandwich while I went with soup and sandwich. For a mere $8, I had an egg salad sandwich and white bean soup. Both were delicious. The soup was warm, hearty, and perfectly seasoned. It was great for a drizzly day. The egg salad sandwich was well balanced - egg wasn't chopped too small, there wasn't an overwhelming amount of mayo, and there was just a slight bite from the mustard. The bread they used was sturdy but not heavy, and I liked their plating with the edible violet.
If I lived in the area, I think this would be my go-to spot for sweets and lazy day lunches.
Sunday, January 11, 2015
Brunch at The 420 Smokehouse
When I was growing up, my parents occasionally took us up to Montreal to visit some close family friends. We fell in love with Schwartz's, a Montreal Hebrew Delicatessen that serves this smoked meat that is to die for.
While planning this Canada trip, I knew that a drive to Montreal would be a bit far, but I hoped to find something similar in Toronto. I looked for restaurants and delis that serve smoked meat and after some searching, came upon The 420 Smokehouse, a restaurant which actually smokes all of their own meat, and which had received rather good Yelp reviews. I immediately sent the menu out to my friends, all of whom quickly approved of it, and we decided to make it our first meal stop in Toronto.
We arrived on a Saturday at around 11:30am, ready for our first meal of the day. It was myself, B., and our two friends. We easily found street parking and headed inside, to the empty restaurant. I was a little surprised that there was no one else there, but our server was friendly, and we picked a cozy table near the window.
We started our meal with some spiked drinks, all of which are 6.50 CAD each. We tried the Ski Jump, which is hot chocolate with Peppermint Schnapps and Frangelico. Unfortunately, we were told that they were out of Frangelico, so we had it with just peppermint. It was okay, but very sweet. We also tried the Spanish coffee (with Kahlua and Brandy) and the Irish coffee (with Irish whiskey and Irish Mist). Both were strong, and were topped with a generous serving of whipped cream and shavings of chocolate.
One of my friends ordered the Breakfast Burger (12 CAD), which is a 4 oz. beef patty with bacon, cheddar cheese, a fried egg, and homefries. He enjoyed it, and actually couldn't even finish all of it.
I ordered the smoked chicken and waffles (12 CAD), which was not very impressive. The plate had two large waffles and two pieces of breaded chicken breast. The serving was large, but the chicken was rather dry and uninspired. I was also a bit disappointed that it was all white meat, as I was hoping for some dark meat (though this may be a little bit my fault, since I didn't ask).
B. ordered the 420 Breakfast which includes 2 eggs any style (he had them poached), with
bacon, lightly smoked sausage, home fries, and toast (11 CAD). The eggs came out a big soft for him, but everything else was fine.
My other friend ordered the smoked meat poutine (large, for $15). This was okay overall. The smoked meat was delicious, but everyone felt that there was a distinct lack of cheese, and the fries seemed to have been tossed in gravy a while before serving, since they were not very crispy. There also wasn't as much gravy as we were hoping there would be. The little bits of smoked in the poutine were so good though, I asked if I could order a plate of this alone. Our waiter asked the kitchen and then told me that a plate would be $8, which was fine by me. It was delicious. Fatty, full bodied smokey flavor that just melted in the mouth. Perfection. This was the best part of the meal.
Our overall brunch experience was just average, but the smoked meat was delicious. I probably would only come back for the meat, but I don't think I'd do brunch here again. Maybe we should have come for the lunch and tried the sandwiches and entrees. Oh well. On to the next meal!
*Other things to note: Service is a bit slow, but friendly. They do have free Wi-Fi. The bathroom is clean.
The 420 Smokehouse
420 Parliament Street
Toronto, ON M5A 3A1
Canada
While planning this Canada trip, I knew that a drive to Montreal would be a bit far, but I hoped to find something similar in Toronto. I looked for restaurants and delis that serve smoked meat and after some searching, came upon The 420 Smokehouse, a restaurant which actually smokes all of their own meat, and which had received rather good Yelp reviews. I immediately sent the menu out to my friends, all of whom quickly approved of it, and we decided to make it our first meal stop in Toronto.
We arrived on a Saturday at around 11:30am, ready for our first meal of the day. It was myself, B., and our two friends. We easily found street parking and headed inside, to the empty restaurant. I was a little surprised that there was no one else there, but our server was friendly, and we picked a cozy table near the window.
We started our meal with some spiked drinks, all of which are 6.50 CAD each. We tried the Ski Jump, which is hot chocolate with Peppermint Schnapps and Frangelico. Unfortunately, we were told that they were out of Frangelico, so we had it with just peppermint. It was okay, but very sweet. We also tried the Spanish coffee (with Kahlua and Brandy) and the Irish coffee (with Irish whiskey and Irish Mist). Both were strong, and were topped with a generous serving of whipped cream and shavings of chocolate.
One of my friends ordered the Breakfast Burger (12 CAD), which is a 4 oz. beef patty with bacon, cheddar cheese, a fried egg, and homefries. He enjoyed it, and actually couldn't even finish all of it.
I ordered the smoked chicken and waffles (12 CAD), which was not very impressive. The plate had two large waffles and two pieces of breaded chicken breast. The serving was large, but the chicken was rather dry and uninspired. I was also a bit disappointed that it was all white meat, as I was hoping for some dark meat (though this may be a little bit my fault, since I didn't ask).
B. ordered the 420 Breakfast which includes 2 eggs any style (he had them poached), with
bacon, lightly smoked sausage, home fries, and toast (11 CAD). The eggs came out a big soft for him, but everything else was fine.
My other friend ordered the smoked meat poutine (large, for $15). This was okay overall. The smoked meat was delicious, but everyone felt that there was a distinct lack of cheese, and the fries seemed to have been tossed in gravy a while before serving, since they were not very crispy. There also wasn't as much gravy as we were hoping there would be. The little bits of smoked in the poutine were so good though, I asked if I could order a plate of this alone. Our waiter asked the kitchen and then told me that a plate would be $8, which was fine by me. It was delicious. Fatty, full bodied smokey flavor that just melted in the mouth. Perfection. This was the best part of the meal.
Our overall brunch experience was just average, but the smoked meat was delicious. I probably would only come back for the meat, but I don't think I'd do brunch here again. Maybe we should have come for the lunch and tried the sandwiches and entrees. Oh well. On to the next meal!
*Other things to note: Service is a bit slow, but friendly. They do have free Wi-Fi. The bathroom is clean.
The 420 Smokehouse
420 Parliament Street
Toronto, ON M5A 3A1
Canada
Sunday, September 21, 2014
Brunch at Public in Manhattan
I have to admit, I'm not a big brunch person. I know, to say this is almost sacrilege, especially considering how much New Yorkers around me seem to love their brunch, but I find the meal to frequently be overpriced and uninspired. I can make delicious pancakes at home, and honestly, charging me more than $14 for poached eggs, no matter what you serve them with, is kind of a rip off. But when my sister up from DC to visit me, she sent me the menu for brunch at Public, and I immediately okay-ed it.
First of all, there is a great variety of creative dishes on the menu, it's not too expensive, and most important of all, I saw a brunch dish that included foie gras. Sold. Get your purse, we're going out to eat.
Because my sister was taking the morning bus from DC to NYC, she ended up arriving at the restaurant before I did. She put our names down for a table, and then sat down at the bar at around 11:30am and ordered a latte while waiting for me. I joined her a little bit before noon. The hostess came and asked if we wanted a table since there was space, but we decided to stay at the bar, since it was brightly lit, not loud, and there was a good view of the restaurant. Plus, it fun to watch the bartenders make everyone's morning cocktails.
After some deliberating over the menu, I ordered the Black Pudding Waffles with red wine poached pears and whipped foie gras butter. This sounded a little risky even to me - the avid lover of all things foie gras - but the bartender assured me it is delicious. I'm glad I decided to try it because it was excellent. I would order this again in a heartbeat. In fact, even as I write this, I am contemplating going back for brunch immediately so that I taste this once more. The waffles were decadent and smooth; if I wasn't told they were made with black pudding, I wouldn't have known, but they had a delicious savoriness that was really nice. I also loved the foie gras butter and poached pear combination. I cleaned my plate.
My sister ordered the Tea-smoked Salmon with poached eggs on multi-grain bread. This was also a big hit. The salmon filet is fragrant from being smoked with tea. The poached egg had a perfectly runny yolk, and we loved how the hearty bread stood up to the flavors and the moistness of the egg yolk. I would be happy to order this again too.
We also were given two little black sesame biscuits, drizzled with lavender honey. The biscuits were alright, but the honey was like heaven. I'd eat that stuff on its own.
For brunch drinks (which, honestly, I wouldn't have ordered, but the bartender kindly gave us two free glasses, perhaps out of pity for the two girls at the bar avidly staring at every drink he sent out to the tables), we tried the Salty Dog, which has gin and grapefruit juice. It was light and refreshing from the grapefruit, but had a fairly strong alcohol kick.
For dessert, my sister and I split the Concord Grape Panna Cotta (not pictured, because, sadly, it wasn't that attractive). This is served with a grape sorbet with prosecco foam and candied peanuts. The peanut and grape combination kind of reminded me of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, minus the bread. Neither my sister nor I were fans of the foam, as it was made with egg whites and was not strongly flavored with prosecco; it tasted kind of strange. The panna cotta was fine, as was the sorbet, but after the amazing main courses, I was expecting a little bit more wow factor from dessert. Maybe my opinion is being swayed by the fact that I don't really like grapes.
My sister got the brunch prix fixe deal which is $24 for a coffee (they let her latte count), entree, and dessert. My dish was $14 (a steal!). Our cocktails were a gift from the bartender and the biscuits were free (I think all tables are given them) so our lovely meal was less than $40 before tip. Not bad for the delicious brunch. I can't wait to go back!
Public
210 Elizabeth St
New York, NY 10012
Tel. 212-343-7011
First of all, there is a great variety of creative dishes on the menu, it's not too expensive, and most important of all, I saw a brunch dish that included foie gras. Sold. Get your purse, we're going out to eat.
Because my sister was taking the morning bus from DC to NYC, she ended up arriving at the restaurant before I did. She put our names down for a table, and then sat down at the bar at around 11:30am and ordered a latte while waiting for me. I joined her a little bit before noon. The hostess came and asked if we wanted a table since there was space, but we decided to stay at the bar, since it was brightly lit, not loud, and there was a good view of the restaurant. Plus, it fun to watch the bartenders make everyone's morning cocktails.
After some deliberating over the menu, I ordered the Black Pudding Waffles with red wine poached pears and whipped foie gras butter. This sounded a little risky even to me - the avid lover of all things foie gras - but the bartender assured me it is delicious. I'm glad I decided to try it because it was excellent. I would order this again in a heartbeat. In fact, even as I write this, I am contemplating going back for brunch immediately so that I taste this once more. The waffles were decadent and smooth; if I wasn't told they were made with black pudding, I wouldn't have known, but they had a delicious savoriness that was really nice. I also loved the foie gras butter and poached pear combination. I cleaned my plate.
My sister ordered the Tea-smoked Salmon with poached eggs on multi-grain bread. This was also a big hit. The salmon filet is fragrant from being smoked with tea. The poached egg had a perfectly runny yolk, and we loved how the hearty bread stood up to the flavors and the moistness of the egg yolk. I would be happy to order this again too.
We also were given two little black sesame biscuits, drizzled with lavender honey. The biscuits were alright, but the honey was like heaven. I'd eat that stuff on its own.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/b1e8f/b1e8f2fb5e47d1e260af3574d51aa4327996c441" alt=""
For dessert, my sister and I split the Concord Grape Panna Cotta (not pictured, because, sadly, it wasn't that attractive). This is served with a grape sorbet with prosecco foam and candied peanuts. The peanut and grape combination kind of reminded me of a peanut butter and jelly sandwich, minus the bread. Neither my sister nor I were fans of the foam, as it was made with egg whites and was not strongly flavored with prosecco; it tasted kind of strange. The panna cotta was fine, as was the sorbet, but after the amazing main courses, I was expecting a little bit more wow factor from dessert. Maybe my opinion is being swayed by the fact that I don't really like grapes.
My sister got the brunch prix fixe deal which is $24 for a coffee (they let her latte count), entree, and dessert. My dish was $14 (a steal!). Our cocktails were a gift from the bartender and the biscuits were free (I think all tables are given them) so our lovely meal was less than $40 before tip. Not bad for the delicious brunch. I can't wait to go back!
Public
210 Elizabeth St
New York, NY 10012
Tel. 212-343-7011
Sunday, July 27, 2014
NYC Restaurant Week Lunch at Riverpark
I wait for restaurant week all year long. It happens twice a year - once in the winter and once in the summer - and as soon as the restaurant list is released, I'm scanning over it and checking the menus for where I want to eat. I have a fairly strict set of criteria for restaurants. I only eat at restaurants that are expensive enough that I might not eat at them normally. If the lunch prix fixe for Restaurant week is $25, I will also not make a reservation at a restaurant where the entrees typically cost around $15 because that's hardly a good deal. And if the restaurant is only offering two choices for the main course and one is chicken and the other is pasta, I also won't eat there. This is partially because I generally find chicken not to be that exciting and partially because, once again, I don't feel like I'm getting my money's worth if I'm paying $25 for chicken that I can buy at the market for less than $2 per pound. And ditto for pasta. So with these criteria in mind, I quickly narrow down my list of potential restaurants to try.
Last year I read some effusively wonderful reviews of the Restaurant Week experience at Tom Colicchio’s Riverpark, on the East side of Manhattan. Main courses for lunch typically run $18 - $25 with desserts from $8 (for simple sorbet or ice cream) to $14. They offer a nice selection of choices for Restaurant Week - more than four options for each course! - so my criteria were met, and I made my reservation.
The only problem with Restaurant Week is that you have to make reservations during the week. For anyone who works and can't easily take a 2-3 hours lunch break, this is difficult. I, luckily (or perhaps unluckily... depends on your point of view), don't work, so I had no problem with this. I couldn't find anyone to go with me though, so I decided to hell with it, it's my birthday, and went to lunch with just the company of a good book, which I figured I would read while waiting in between courses. Both the hostess and my waiter seemed very sympathetic to the fact that I was dining alone. I don't know if this was because I had noted that it was my birthday when I made the reservation, so they pitied the girl celebrating alone, or if it was because they seated me outside, where I just happened to be surrounded by couples, romantically enjoying each other's presence. Either way, I wasn't particularly bothered.
My lunch began with the Sweet Corn Panna Cotta. It was served with a corn salad, avocado, lime crème fraîche, and huitlacoche (apparently a type of corn fungus???) vinaigrette. I was not a big fan of any of the items accompanying the panna cotta (and this was before I came home and google told me that one of the ingredients was corn fungus). The corn salad was fine but I honestly couldn't tell if it was fresh corn or canned corn, which is kind of sad. The avocado was rather over-salted/over-seasoned and the vinaigrette was far too strong. I loved the corn panna cotta though. The texture was on point - quiveringly light - and the flavor was stellar. I'd order it again in a heartbeat, I just wouldn't waste my time eating anything else on the plate.
The bread served with the meal is in the form of a mini baguette, served with good cold butter. It was really good; light, with a nice crust. I finished my first one with my appetizer, and was asked if I wanted more with my entree. (The answer to that is always yes.)
My main course was the Lamb Ribs and Sausage, served with tempura artichokes, olives, almonds, and a yogurt sauce. My ribs were scorched. By that, I mean, they arrived at the table black. I had to scrape off the burnt outside layer, and then sadly found that the meat was over-seasoned. I was also not a big fan of the yogurt sauce. The sausage was a bit dry, but not bad. The biggest problem was that this was just not a good summer dish. It felt heavy and I was tired of it after a few bites. The fish dishes being ordered around me looked far tastier and I wish I had ordered that instead.
I was given - for free - a side of grilled okra (typically $6). I was unsure if this was because it was my birthday or because they felt pity for me because I was dining alone. Either way, it was a nice touch and I enjoyed the veggies, but they were also fairly scorched. Is this the new style? Maybe I'm just unsophisticated.
For dessert, I had the Basil Cream Puff served with strawberries, granola, and strawberry sorbet. This was amazing. Really. The basil cream puff was so fragrant, and the combination with the fresh strawberries and the sorbet was on point. I wish I could have had two more servings of this. I enjoyed every single spoonful.
The service was very friendly. I got a happy birthday message on my menu and a candle on my dessert. The timing of the dishes was also good. It was a leisurely meal, and I never felt rushed, but I never felt that service was slow.
While I was fairly disappointed by my main course, I don't think the lamb is normally scorched that way, and I did enjoy both of my other dishes. I had a good overall experience and left full. I had been so looking forward to Riverpark though, I couldn't decide if they let me down or if it was a fluke, so I wanted to give them another chance. I don't typically do this, but I decided to go back for another Restaurant Week lunch (and this time, I did have company).
On my second visit, I started with the house cured Atlantic salmon, which is a fairly simple dish. It was rather generously salted, but that only encouraged me to eat their bread, which is quite good. I also enjoyed the slightly brined cucumbers.
For my main course I ordered the merluza, which is a white fish served with heirloom tomatoes and faro. A tomato consumme is poured on top, tableside. I really loved this dish. It was light, fragrant, and perfect for summer. The tomatoes provided a lovely accompanying acidity to the flaky fish, and the texture of the faro was perfect. There was nothing to complain about.
For my dessert, I considered trying the peach cobbler, but I had so enjoyed the basil cream puffs with raspberry sorbet the last time I was here that I wanted to order it again. It did not disappoint.
Amusingly, I had the same waiter for lunch that I had had for my previous lunch. He remembered me (I suppose it's hard to forget an Asian girl who dines alone on her birthday), and service was just as friendly and attentive as it had been the first time.
The seating area outside is beautiful. As their website describes, this restaurant is located in a "garden plaza with romantic East River views." What they fail to mention is the construction going on around the area, or the sounds of traffic which you can clearly hear if you sit outside. However, neither of these things bothered me. The area is very comfortable, with pillows on the "booth" sides and a nice breeze coming off the water and the shade from the building keeps you cool, even when it's hot out.
In general, I think Riverpark earned itself a solid B. There's definitely room for improvement in terms of seasoning (less salt!) and cooking (there's a difference between a nice char and a terrible scorch), but the creativity and flavors are there, if they can just get down the execution. For $25, it's not a bad deal.
Riverpark
450 E 29th St.
New York, NY 10016
Tel. 212.729.9790
Last year I read some effusively wonderful reviews of the Restaurant Week experience at Tom Colicchio’s Riverpark, on the East side of Manhattan. Main courses for lunch typically run $18 - $25 with desserts from $8 (for simple sorbet or ice cream) to $14. They offer a nice selection of choices for Restaurant Week - more than four options for each course! - so my criteria were met, and I made my reservation.
The only problem with Restaurant Week is that you have to make reservations during the week. For anyone who works and can't easily take a 2-3 hours lunch break, this is difficult. I, luckily (or perhaps unluckily... depends on your point of view), don't work, so I had no problem with this. I couldn't find anyone to go with me though, so I decided to hell with it, it's my birthday, and went to lunch with just the company of a good book, which I figured I would read while waiting in between courses. Both the hostess and my waiter seemed very sympathetic to the fact that I was dining alone. I don't know if this was because I had noted that it was my birthday when I made the reservation, so they pitied the girl celebrating alone, or if it was because they seated me outside, where I just happened to be surrounded by couples, romantically enjoying each other's presence. Either way, I wasn't particularly bothered.
The bread served with the meal is in the form of a mini baguette, served with good cold butter. It was really good; light, with a nice crust. I finished my first one with my appetizer, and was asked if I wanted more with my entree. (The answer to that is always yes.)
My main course was the Lamb Ribs and Sausage, served with tempura artichokes, olives, almonds, and a yogurt sauce. My ribs were scorched. By that, I mean, they arrived at the table black. I had to scrape off the burnt outside layer, and then sadly found that the meat was over-seasoned. I was also not a big fan of the yogurt sauce. The sausage was a bit dry, but not bad. The biggest problem was that this was just not a good summer dish. It felt heavy and I was tired of it after a few bites. The fish dishes being ordered around me looked far tastier and I wish I had ordered that instead.
I was given - for free - a side of grilled okra (typically $6). I was unsure if this was because it was my birthday or because they felt pity for me because I was dining alone. Either way, it was a nice touch and I enjoyed the veggies, but they were also fairly scorched. Is this the new style? Maybe I'm just unsophisticated.
For dessert, I had the Basil Cream Puff served with strawberries, granola, and strawberry sorbet. This was amazing. Really. The basil cream puff was so fragrant, and the combination with the fresh strawberries and the sorbet was on point. I wish I could have had two more servings of this. I enjoyed every single spoonful.
The service was very friendly. I got a happy birthday message on my menu and a candle on my dessert. The timing of the dishes was also good. It was a leisurely meal, and I never felt rushed, but I never felt that service was slow.
![]() |
Cured salmon appetizer (left) and merluza with faro and heirloom tomatoes main course (right) |
On my second visit, I started with the house cured Atlantic salmon, which is a fairly simple dish. It was rather generously salted, but that only encouraged me to eat their bread, which is quite good. I also enjoyed the slightly brined cucumbers.
For my main course I ordered the merluza, which is a white fish served with heirloom tomatoes and faro. A tomato consumme is poured on top, tableside. I really loved this dish. It was light, fragrant, and perfect for summer. The tomatoes provided a lovely accompanying acidity to the flaky fish, and the texture of the faro was perfect. There was nothing to complain about.
For my dessert, I considered trying the peach cobbler, but I had so enjoyed the basil cream puffs with raspberry sorbet the last time I was here that I wanted to order it again. It did not disappoint.
Amusingly, I had the same waiter for lunch that I had had for my previous lunch. He remembered me (I suppose it's hard to forget an Asian girl who dines alone on her birthday), and service was just as friendly and attentive as it had been the first time.
The seating area outside is beautiful. As their website describes, this restaurant is located in a "garden plaza with romantic East River views." What they fail to mention is the construction going on around the area, or the sounds of traffic which you can clearly hear if you sit outside. However, neither of these things bothered me. The area is very comfortable, with pillows on the "booth" sides and a nice breeze coming off the water and the shade from the building keeps you cool, even when it's hot out.
In general, I think Riverpark earned itself a solid B. There's definitely room for improvement in terms of seasoning (less salt!) and cooking (there's a difference between a nice char and a terrible scorch), but the creativity and flavors are there, if they can just get down the execution. For $25, it's not a bad deal.
Riverpark
450 E 29th St.
New York, NY 10016
Tel. 212.729.9790
Monday, July 15, 2013
Cronuts - a food trend that the Foodie Next Door had to try
Anyone who keeps track of food fads or reads the news regarding trends in New York City (or in the USA even) should know about Dominique Ansel's Cronuts.
The cronut craze has literally swept the nation. Bakeries in big cities like LA, DC, and Chicago are taking note of the huge success of this new baked good and selling knock-off creations called doughssants, cray-nuts, and doissants.
So what are these things? They are hybrids: half-doughnut, half-croissant. A flaky, deep-fried pastry filled with sweetened cream, rolled in sugar, and glazed. And apparently something about these creations has them in high demand because even though they are selling at $5 a pop, people have been lining up outside Dominique Ansel Bakery in Soho for up to 3 hours to wait for theirs. The cronuts are so popular that people start waiting around 5 or 6am and the bakery sells out each morning within a couple hours of opening, even though each customer is limited to two cronuts. Cronut popularity is such that people have started scalping theirs for $20-40!
Still on vacation and now happily settled into our new apartment just 20 minutes outside of Manhattan, B. and I decided to give up some precious sleep one morning and see just how good these things could be. We woke up at 4:45am, took the train into the city and groggily got in line. We decided to do this on a weekday, just to make sure we weren't standing in line just to have them sell out before we got to try one. This ended up being a very good plan, because when we got in line, there were only about 20 people or so in front of us. The line quickly got longer though, and stretched around the corner and down the block as it got closer to opening time.
When the doors opened at 8am, Dominique Ansel himself came out and allowed a wave of people inside. Of course, as luck would have it, B. and I were at the exact cut off point and so we had to wait outside. But then a girl from the bakery came out with a tray of fresh, hot madeleines. Each person in line was allowed to have one. It was so nice, especially after a long wait.
At last, we were allowed inside. The line moved quickly and efficiently, as the cronuts are pre-boxed and almost everyone knew exactly what they wanted. Because of the new limit of 2 cronuts per order, B. and I split up so that he could order two and I could order two. I was afraid this might be a bit excessive, especially since that total order came to $21.78 (post-tax), but in the end I'm glad we got that many.
There was space at a table in front, so we sat down to eat ours right away. B. saw how good they looked and declined my offer to split one, saying that he wanted his all to himself.
The first bite immediately showed the complex texture of the treat. The fried, sugar coated exterior gives ways to a pleasantly chewy interior, much like a yeasted doughnut, except that it has an airy quality to it. On the second bite, I got some of the filling - vanilla crème and blackberry jam. The jam had some acid to it, which perfectly balanced the sweet and fat of the cronut. The glaze was very sweet (clearly the ingredients were mostly sugar and very little actual flavoring) and a bit of an overkill since there was already a sugar coating. The cronut is very filling. You can definitely feel the calories from the butter of the dough and the fat from the frying. If it hadn't been for the very long wait, I don't think I would have been able to eat an entire one.
Overall, we both enjoyed our cronuts, but the price tag is a hefty one. I'd never pay more than about $2.50 for a croissant, and a doughnut needs to be really good for me to consider it worth $3.50, so this cronut cost significantly more than I'd be willing to pay for its parents. The cronut also didn't have the flakiness I would expect from something that is supposed to be half-croissant.
Would I like to eat one again? Sure. Would I like to wait 3 hours in line and pay $5? No, thank you.
Dominique Ansel Bakery
189 Spring St (between Sullivan & Thompson)
New York, NY 10012
Tel: 212-219-2773
Hours: 8am to 7pm (Monday to Saturday)
9am to 7pm (Sunday)
Closest subway stops: Spring St (C-E) or Prince St (N-R-W)
The cronut craze has literally swept the nation. Bakeries in big cities like LA, DC, and Chicago are taking note of the huge success of this new baked good and selling knock-off creations called doughssants, cray-nuts, and doissants.
So what are these things? They are hybrids: half-doughnut, half-croissant. A flaky, deep-fried pastry filled with sweetened cream, rolled in sugar, and glazed. And apparently something about these creations has them in high demand because even though they are selling at $5 a pop, people have been lining up outside Dominique Ansel Bakery in Soho for up to 3 hours to wait for theirs. The cronuts are so popular that people start waiting around 5 or 6am and the bakery sells out each morning within a couple hours of opening, even though each customer is limited to two cronuts. Cronut popularity is such that people have started scalping theirs for $20-40!
When the doors opened at 8am, Dominique Ansel himself came out and allowed a wave of people inside. Of course, as luck would have it, B. and I were at the exact cut off point and so we had to wait outside. But then a girl from the bakery came out with a tray of fresh, hot madeleines. Each person in line was allowed to have one. It was so nice, especially after a long wait.
At last, we were allowed inside. The line moved quickly and efficiently, as the cronuts are pre-boxed and almost everyone knew exactly what they wanted. Because of the new limit of 2 cronuts per order, B. and I split up so that he could order two and I could order two. I was afraid this might be a bit excessive, especially since that total order came to $21.78 (post-tax), but in the end I'm glad we got that many.
The first bite immediately showed the complex texture of the treat. The fried, sugar coated exterior gives ways to a pleasantly chewy interior, much like a yeasted doughnut, except that it has an airy quality to it. On the second bite, I got some of the filling - vanilla crème and blackberry jam. The jam had some acid to it, which perfectly balanced the sweet and fat of the cronut. The glaze was very sweet (clearly the ingredients were mostly sugar and very little actual flavoring) and a bit of an overkill since there was already a sugar coating. The cronut is very filling. You can definitely feel the calories from the butter of the dough and the fat from the frying. If it hadn't been for the very long wait, I don't think I would have been able to eat an entire one.
Would I like to eat one again? Sure. Would I like to wait 3 hours in line and pay $5? No, thank you.
Dominique Ansel Bakery
189 Spring St (between Sullivan & Thompson)
New York, NY 10012
Tel: 212-219-2773
Hours: 8am to 7pm (Monday to Saturday)
9am to 7pm (Sunday)
Closest subway stops: Spring St (C-E) or Prince St (N-R-W)
Friday, November 30, 2012
Lunch at Blue Duck Tavern
Following our engagement, B. and I went to eat with my mother at a restaurant in DC that my parents and I fell in love with a few years back during restaurant week. Incredibly enough, it has take me four months to write about it. Such is the life of someone in medical school. (B. insists that he knows what he is getting into.)
Located in the Park Hyatt Hotel, Blue Duck Tavern is a lovely contemporary style restaurant serving new American cuisine. Their menu is set up to "recognize the purveyors and artisans who enrich [the] menu with their fresh ingredients," so each course has listed beside it the area from which it came.
Our party of three was promptly seated and we mulled over the choices offer on the menu before finally settling on our selections. Having eaten there before, my mom and I knew that the main courses were large enough to be more than enough for a full meal; no need for starters or sides.
B. ordered the veal "schnitzel" with mustard spaetzle and mushroom sauce (from Chapel Hill, NC, $20). It was earthy and full of character, but the kitchen has still managed to keep the veal light. It had great texture, and we all liked that the layer of breading was just right; not too thick, and not at all greasy. Both my mom and I felt that it was missing high notes or a fresh acidity that a salad or fresh vegetables might have provided, but B. liked that it was fairly traditional. My mom and I gave it a 8.5 out of 10. B. gave it a 9 out of 10.
I ordered the wood oven roasted confit of duck leg served with frisee, a poached egg, and warm bacon vinaigrette (from Grimaud Garms, CA, $20). The salad was very beautifully dressed. I am not normally impressed with salads, but this one definitely stood out. The acidity and body of the vinaigrette was the perfect foil for the duck confit. I love the sweet, crunchy Kalamata olives and the wobbly, perfectly "saucy" poached egg. Everything together was lovely. All the elements worked together, and I gave it a 9 out of 10 overall. The duck was good, but alone I felt that it was only a 7 out of 10, as it wasn't as moist as I was hoping.
My mom ordered the crispy skin salmon, served with cucumber, hearts of palm, smoked roe, and sorrel cream (from Sitka, AK $23). The dish truly lived up to its name, as the skin on the salmon was beautifully crispy, while the fish was perfect moist and light. The sorrel cream, hearts of palm, and cucumber provided a fresh and light spring element to the dish. We gave it an 8.5 out of 10.
For dessert, we were all approaching fullness, so we decided that among the three of us, we would split two desserts. Every day there is a "Market Dessert" that is offered on the menu, and this changes with the seasons. When our waiter described their market dessert for the day, it sounded too good to pass up.
The Market Dessert of the day was a peach and rosemary tart served with vanilla creme fraiche and candied rosemary ($9). The roasted peaches sat on a dense olive oil cake (I wouldn't call it a tart, as it was more sponge-y than crumbly). It was a very creative dessert. The candied rosemary was very interesting, though I think had the kitchen fried the rosemary, it would have been more fragrant and effective. We loved the combination of the creme fraiche, peach puree, olive oil cake, and roasted peaches together. It was a very satisfying dessert. We gave it an 8.5 out of 10.
The other dessert we ordered was the milk chocolate banana s'mores ($9). This was rich in flavor but light and playful. I absolutely loved the brûléed mashmallow and the thin banana chip. The graham cracker crumbs went well with the milk chocolate. I do not know quite how to describe the milk chocolate part, except that it was like a cross between a panna cotta and a pot de creme. It was silky, creamy, and light. We gave it an 8 out of 10.
In the end, we were very satisfied and full, and as usual, we had perfect service throughout the meal. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the area.
Blue Duck Tavern
1201 24th Street NW
Washington, DC 20037
Tel. (202) 419-6755
Located in the Park Hyatt Hotel, Blue Duck Tavern is a lovely contemporary style restaurant serving new American cuisine. Their menu is set up to "recognize the purveyors and artisans who enrich [the] menu with their fresh ingredients," so each course has listed beside it the area from which it came.
Our party of three was promptly seated and we mulled over the choices offer on the menu before finally settling on our selections. Having eaten there before, my mom and I knew that the main courses were large enough to be more than enough for a full meal; no need for starters or sides.
B. ordered the veal "schnitzel" with mustard spaetzle and mushroom sauce (from Chapel Hill, NC, $20). It was earthy and full of character, but the kitchen has still managed to keep the veal light. It had great texture, and we all liked that the layer of breading was just right; not too thick, and not at all greasy. Both my mom and I felt that it was missing high notes or a fresh acidity that a salad or fresh vegetables might have provided, but B. liked that it was fairly traditional. My mom and I gave it a 8.5 out of 10. B. gave it a 9 out of 10.
I ordered the wood oven roasted confit of duck leg served with frisee, a poached egg, and warm bacon vinaigrette (from Grimaud Garms, CA, $20). The salad was very beautifully dressed. I am not normally impressed with salads, but this one definitely stood out. The acidity and body of the vinaigrette was the perfect foil for the duck confit. I love the sweet, crunchy Kalamata olives and the wobbly, perfectly "saucy" poached egg. Everything together was lovely. All the elements worked together, and I gave it a 9 out of 10 overall. The duck was good, but alone I felt that it was only a 7 out of 10, as it wasn't as moist as I was hoping.
My mom ordered the crispy skin salmon, served with cucumber, hearts of palm, smoked roe, and sorrel cream (from Sitka, AK $23). The dish truly lived up to its name, as the skin on the salmon was beautifully crispy, while the fish was perfect moist and light. The sorrel cream, hearts of palm, and cucumber provided a fresh and light spring element to the dish. We gave it an 8.5 out of 10.
For dessert, we were all approaching fullness, so we decided that among the three of us, we would split two desserts. Every day there is a "Market Dessert" that is offered on the menu, and this changes with the seasons. When our waiter described their market dessert for the day, it sounded too good to pass up.
The Market Dessert of the day was a peach and rosemary tart served with vanilla creme fraiche and candied rosemary ($9). The roasted peaches sat on a dense olive oil cake (I wouldn't call it a tart, as it was more sponge-y than crumbly). It was a very creative dessert. The candied rosemary was very interesting, though I think had the kitchen fried the rosemary, it would have been more fragrant and effective. We loved the combination of the creme fraiche, peach puree, olive oil cake, and roasted peaches together. It was a very satisfying dessert. We gave it an 8.5 out of 10.
The other dessert we ordered was the milk chocolate banana s'mores ($9). This was rich in flavor but light and playful. I absolutely loved the brûléed mashmallow and the thin banana chip. The graham cracker crumbs went well with the milk chocolate. I do not know quite how to describe the milk chocolate part, except that it was like a cross between a panna cotta and a pot de creme. It was silky, creamy, and light. We gave it an 8 out of 10.
In the end, we were very satisfied and full, and as usual, we had perfect service throughout the meal. I highly recommend this restaurant to anyone in the area.
Blue Duck Tavern
1201 24th Street NW
Washington, DC 20037
Tel. (202) 419-6755
Tuesday, August 28, 2012
Dinner at the Salon at Per Se
I have wanted to eat at Per Se for quite a while now. Per Se opened in 2004 as the little sister to Chef Thomas Keller's famous California restaurant, The French Laundry. Located in the Upper West Side of New York City, Per Se serves its diners thoughtfully conceived dishes with elegant presentation while they look out across Central Park. As Sam Sifton wrote in his review in The New York Times, "[t]he restaurant more handsomely rewards the companionship of those who love one another as much as they do pleasure and indulgence."
The menu at Per Se changes daily, although some standards remain. The restaurant serves small, focused dishes that are made to be a tasting experience. Typically, meals at Per Se are prix fixe, with the standard ten course tasting menu set at $295 (service included). Reservations can be made up to one month in advance.
For those who don't have the time to dial and re-dial desperately a month before their desired dinner date and who perhaps don't want to invest in at ten course meal, Per Se also offers the option of dining in the salon. The salon does not require a reservation and you really don't need to make one -- it seems that few people know about or decide to take this option available for dining. The menu in the salon is a la carte and includes dishes from the tasting menu. This was the option that B. and I chose for the occasion of our post-engagement celebration.
We simply walked in and asked to be seated in the salon, where we were offered a choice of seating in elegant armchairs with a coffee table or at a high glass bar with tall stools. I chose the high glass bar because the lighting was better in that area and I am always thinking about how my food will look. Also, I thought it would be more comfortable to have a table at the proper height, rather than bending down to a coffee table to eat. I was hoping there might be a place I might put my purse other than on the table we were eating at or on the floor, so when I asked our waiter, he very kindly brought over a small wooden table for my purse. I also forgot to bring something to write on, so I requested paper and a pen, which he also provided, no questions asked. This was just the beginning of a night of excellent and attentive service.
To start our meal, we were given two small Gruyere cheese gougeres. These little balls (on the right) were light and fluffy. That one bite was so perfect in its warm depth of flavor that it had me both satisfied and craving a hundred more.
Each of us was also given a salmon cornet with a sesame tuile and sweet red onion creme fraiche. This cold amuse bouche contrasted nicely with the warm gougeres and the sesame tuile provided the perfect crunch. It was great how such a small bite could offer textural contrasts as well as acidity, fat, and creaminess. Both of these little bites were a great start to what would be a delicious meal.
Then out came the bread basket, which had (starting from left to right) three little pretzel rolls, three sourdough boules, and three French baguettes. We were also given butter from Loire Valley and two types of salt - a grey sea salt and a pink Hawaiian salt. We tried everything. My favorite was the little French baguettes as the crust had the perfect amount of crisp bite to it while the inside was light and airy. The other bread options were also fantastic. I think between the two of us, B. and I managed to eat almost everything in the bread basket.
For my meal, I chose the "Terrine" of Hudson Valley Moulard Duck Foie Gras ($40) which was served with Macerated Blackberries, Celery Branch "Ribbons," Black Walnut Coulis, Toasted Oats and Tellicherry Peppercorn "Aigre-Doux." In a lovely linen napkin, I was also given a fresh brioche roll, which was warm and salted; a piece of this was like eating air. Each time I finished my brioche, I was given a new one in a fresh linen. Our waiter brought me four in total and I ate them so quickly sometimes I had to wait a bit between for a new one to come out. I've read from other diners that if you take a while to eat the brioche, they bring you out a fresh warm one, even if you haven't finished the one on your plate; this, however, was not a problem for me.
The foie gras was very good. It truly melted in the mouth and the entire dish was very well executed. I didn't have a single complaint, except that I could have continued eating another entire plate of this, rich though it might be. The plate was designed as a wonderful experience, so that a bite of the foie gras with the celery branch was different from a bite with the toast oats, and a bite with everything together was a symphony of flavors. This was a 9.5 out of 10. To pair with this, I ordered a glass of white wine, a sweet Sauternes, 2001 ($45).
The menu at Per Se changes daily, although some standards remain. The restaurant serves small, focused dishes that are made to be a tasting experience. Typically, meals at Per Se are prix fixe, with the standard ten course tasting menu set at $295 (service included). Reservations can be made up to one month in advance.
For those who don't have the time to dial and re-dial desperately a month before their desired dinner date and who perhaps don't want to invest in at ten course meal, Per Se also offers the option of dining in the salon. The salon does not require a reservation and you really don't need to make one -- it seems that few people know about or decide to take this option available for dining. The menu in the salon is a la carte and includes dishes from the tasting menu. This was the option that B. and I chose for the occasion of our post-engagement celebration.
We simply walked in and asked to be seated in the salon, where we were offered a choice of seating in elegant armchairs with a coffee table or at a high glass bar with tall stools. I chose the high glass bar because the lighting was better in that area and I am always thinking about how my food will look. Also, I thought it would be more comfortable to have a table at the proper height, rather than bending down to a coffee table to eat. I was hoping there might be a place I might put my purse other than on the table we were eating at or on the floor, so when I asked our waiter, he very kindly brought over a small wooden table for my purse. I also forgot to bring something to write on, so I requested paper and a pen, which he also provided, no questions asked. This was just the beginning of a night of excellent and attentive service.
To start our meal, we were given two small Gruyere cheese gougeres. These little balls (on the right) were light and fluffy. That one bite was so perfect in its warm depth of flavor that it had me both satisfied and craving a hundred more.
Each of us was also given a salmon cornet with a sesame tuile and sweet red onion creme fraiche. This cold amuse bouche contrasted nicely with the warm gougeres and the sesame tuile provided the perfect crunch. It was great how such a small bite could offer textural contrasts as well as acidity, fat, and creaminess. Both of these little bites were a great start to what would be a delicious meal.
Then out came the bread basket, which had (starting from left to right) three little pretzel rolls, three sourdough boules, and three French baguettes. We were also given butter from Loire Valley and two types of salt - a grey sea salt and a pink Hawaiian salt. We tried everything. My favorite was the little French baguettes as the crust had the perfect amount of crisp bite to it while the inside was light and airy. The other bread options were also fantastic. I think between the two of us, B. and I managed to eat almost everything in the bread basket.
For my meal, I chose the "Terrine" of Hudson Valley Moulard Duck Foie Gras ($40) which was served with Macerated Blackberries, Celery Branch "Ribbons," Black Walnut Coulis, Toasted Oats and Tellicherry Peppercorn "Aigre-Doux." In a lovely linen napkin, I was also given a fresh brioche roll, which was warm and salted; a piece of this was like eating air. Each time I finished my brioche, I was given a new one in a fresh linen. Our waiter brought me four in total and I ate them so quickly sometimes I had to wait a bit between for a new one to come out. I've read from other diners that if you take a while to eat the brioche, they bring you out a fresh warm one, even if you haven't finished the one on your plate; this, however, was not a problem for me.
The foie gras was very good. It truly melted in the mouth and the entire dish was very well executed. I didn't have a single complaint, except that I could have continued eating another entire plate of this, rich though it might be. The plate was designed as a wonderful experience, so that a bite of the foie gras with the celery branch was different from a bite with the toast oats, and a bite with everything together was a symphony of flavors. This was a 9.5 out of 10. To pair with this, I ordered a glass of white wine, a sweet Sauternes, 2001 ($45).
For his meal, B. ordered the Herb Roasted Thomas Farm's Squab ($36) with Garden State Sweet Corn, Poached Bing Cherries, Braised Swiss Chard and "Sauce Périgourdine." This was incredible. It definitely had a wow factor. The squab was cooked to the perfect pinkness and the corn, Bing cherries (pitted, but left whole), and Swiss chard all married together beautifully. Again, this was a 9.5 out of 10. To pair with this, B. had glass of an Italian Brunello ($55), for which I forgot to mark the year. He liked this, as he enjoys more oak-y wines, and it went well with his dish.
I really appreciated that even though we were ordering by the glass, the servers still came and poured us a taste to sample first, to make sure we liked what we were ordering, before they filled our glasses. They also let us keep our bread basket even after our main courses were cleared, since we enjoyed munching on the bread so much. There was no feeling of being rushed.
For dessert, we decided on the creme brulee with ginger snap cookies ($20). This was served with red verjus gelee. There was a very nice layer of caramelized sugar on top, which cracked gorgeously under the tapping of my spoon. My favorite part though was the soft and fragrant ginger cookies, which I could have happily had a plate of one their own, maybe with a glass of milk. The verjus gelee was a nice touch and the creme brulee was very good, but I felt like it was missing a wow factor. B. and I both agreed that this was not the best creme brulee either of us had ever eaten. We gave it an 8 out of 10.
After dessert, we were bought a 3 tiered mignardises tray. There was white verjus and red current pate de fruits which were sour and flavorful, white chocolates filled with sesame and mango which were very dense and rich (though I didn't get a strong sense of the mango flavor), and almond nougat with raspberries which was sweet and sticky.
To take home, we were also given two little packets of raspberry shortbreads to have for breakfast the next day. They were very good with coffee; sweet and sandy in a lovely way, the only thing they needed was a very light sprinkle of salt to elevate their flavors.
Overall, Per Se was an excellent experience with wonderful service. All of the wait staff were friendly and kind, and it was not at all over imposing. They were attentive, without overdoing it. I would be happy to return and to sample more of the menu. B. and I even joked about having our wedding reception at Per Se.
Of course, the meal comes with a hefty price tag -- even higher if you commit to the full tasting menu -- but you are paying for an experience, and what a wonderful experience it was.
Per Se
10 Columbus Circle at 60th St.
Time Warner Center - 4th floor
New York, NY 10019
Tel. 212-823-9335
Thursday, August 9, 2012
Lunch at Mesa Grill & big news
This year Summer Restaurant Week in NYC was July 16th to August 10th. I read over the list of participating restaurants and immediately knew I wanted to eat at Iron Chef Bobby Flay's Mesa Grill. Mesa Grill's Restaurant Week menu looked very good, and so I made a reservation for me and my boyfriend, B. to have lunch last Friday. I went to work that morning and he ran some errands in the city and we met up at the restaurant for our reservation at 1:30pm. We were seated promptly by the window and after we ordered, we got a lovely basket of jalapeno cornbread and white bread with salted whipped butter. Both breads were very good, though the white bread was more satisfying and sturdy, as the cornbread fell apart very quickly as we ate it.
I also ordered a cactus pear margarita with tequila, lime juice, cactus pear juice, and a lovely salted rim. It was a very bright pink, a color which matched it strong flavor profile. It was more sour than expected, but I did enjoy it.
Our meal was three courses, prix fixe, for $24.07.
My man, the soup, and the drink |
I started my meal with the Spicy Salmon Tartare with Crisp Hominy Cake, Piquillo Pesto and Cilantro Vinaigrette. This was delicious. The cold salmon with the hot hominy cake contrasted each other perfectly, and the pesto and vinaigrette combined to highlight the flavor of the fish. I adored the textures and flavors of the dish. I wouldn't hesitate to order this again. It was a strong 9 out of 10.
For his main course, B. ordered the Sixteen Spice Chicken Skewers with Mint, Butter Lettuce, Pickled Red Onions and Mesa Barbecue Sauce. The chicken was incredibly moist, tender, and flavorful. It was not powerfully spicy, which I appreciated. The pickled onions were a nice accompaniment and I liked that the bbq sauce was served on the side. Another very well executed dish, we gave this an 8 out of 10.
For my main course, I ordered the Wild Striped Bass with Roasted Corn Sauce, Jalapeno Pesto and Charred Corn-Tomato Salsa. The fish was perfectly cooked, flaky and moist. I cannot say how much I adored the pesto, salsa, and corn sauce. It was an absolute symphony of flavors that worked very well with the fish. Bobby Flay has a way of skillfully combining numerous flavors and elements without overwhelming or drowning the main component. I was wow-ed by each bite I took. A strong 9.5 out of 10.
For dessert, I ordered the Caramel Chocolate Pudding with Malted Whipped Cream. I can't turn down anything with caramel and chocolate in it, and I am glad I ordered this. It was light, silky smooth, and delicious. The caramel flavor complimented the dark chocolate wonderfully, and the malted whipped cream was a great topping. An 8.5 out of 10.
The other dessert we ate was the Vanilla Bean Custard with Summer Berry Salad. This was incredible. By this point of the meal, we were both so full, but we didn't want to stop. The dessert was just too good not to eat. It was ethereal, delicate, and melted in the mouth in the most heavenly way imaginable. I honestly could not imagine a way that this dessert could have been improved. It was a 10 out of 10.
Our overall experience was Mesa Grill was wonderful. There was great service, wonderful food, and a lovely atmosphere.
Afterwards I was in such a food coma, I wanted to just curl up with my boyfriend on a couch and nap, but he told me he wanted to meet up with his friend and former co-worker, so we headed out to Central Park. My stomach was full of food and I was sleepy, so I walked with my eyes half closed while we ambled down a beautiful path lined with benches and trees. B. asked me if I wanted to sit down on a bench for a moment, and I foolishly said no, because I was so tired, I was afraid if I sat down I would never get up again. Thankfully, I gave in after a moment and settled down next to him.
He took my hand and there, on a bench in Central Park, everything changed.
When he asked me the question, I told him, "You know what my answer is." I said yes. He slid the ring on my finger, I forgot about everything else in world, and we kissed. There had been a band playing by us and they stopped to look at the couple that had just gotten engaged.
I wish I could tell you how happy I am, how sweet this day was, and how blissfully in love we are, but it is all more than words can say. I have never known love like this. I have never known joy like this. I have never known a man like this. And so, I am engaged.
Monday, April 23, 2012
Sweet Paris - Ladurée versus Pierre Hermé
Two weeks ago (has it been two weeks already?) I flew to France to see B., to meet his family, and to soak up the sweetness that is Paris. Of course, when I talk about the sweetness that is Paris, I do mean that rather literally. I have a long-standing love for French pastries — a love that almost matches my love for B. — and I don't deprive myself when I can get them. In fact, I just counted, and during the six days that I was in Paris, I ate 12 different pastries. Twelve. And I don't even think of that as a lot. A visit to Paris is so synonymous in my mind with eating pastries that I don't think of it as anything to write home about; most of the time I don't take notes or pictures, and all my friends and family know that I always take pictures of my food. But with French pastries, either because I grew up seeing them all the time or because I don't want to wait the extra 20 seconds to take a decent picture, I just buy them and I eat them. But there are two places in Paris that are too famous to act blasé about: Ladurée and Pierre Hermé.
I first went to Ladurée when I was thirteen. This was many years ago, before the name was well-known in the States. It was a place that my parents had read about and they decided to take their two daughters there. We sat down in the salon and oohed and aaahed over everything as we ate the pastries and drank the tea. It was wonderful. The service was friendly and attentive and everything was delicious, but I haven't been back since. Ladurée is good, but pastries everywhere in Paris are good, and I never really got into the macaron food fad that everyone else seems to be following. Sure, I enjoy the delicate little rounds, but I'd rather have some good foie gras.
Recently, however, when my boyfriend came to visit, he brought two boxes of macarons for my family from Ladurée, sweetly packed and carried across the ocean for us. My sister and my parents were touched by his gesture, and it piqued my interest in going back to the shop.
Ladurée, which was founded back in 1862 (a fact that is printed on almost everything that bears their name, so I think they're rather proud of it), is often credited as being the first place in which the modern-day macaron was made. The modern-day macaron I speak of is a tiny "cake" (if one can even use that word) made of egg whites, almond flour, and sugar baked into small airy rounds that are smooth, crisp, and soft all at once. Two of these small "shells" are joined together by a ganache or jelly-like filling in the middle. Flavors can range from raspberry and chocolate to olive oil or thyme.
I first visited Pierre Hermé two summers ago. I had heard much about it for years before then, but I just hadn't taken the time to visit. Pierre Hermé (the man) is famous in the gourmet pastry scene for his bold, sometimes risky, flavor pairings, including the very famous Ispahan, a macaron that combines raspberry, lychee, and rose together so successfully that it has been copied everywhere, including at Ladurée.
My sister and I went there together, and we didn't try any of the macarons (again, I was never big into the macaron craze), but we bought the Ispahan and a dark chocolate mousse pastry. I remember that the Ispahan was good, but I don't recall being blown away by it.
But I am no longer eighteen and it has been a long time since I was thirteen, and so I had to go back. I wanted to do a taste test between the two places and to compare the macarons at Pierre Hermé with those at Ladurée.
At Ladurée I bought several macarons, for 1€70 a piece. Boxes are more expensive, but are a good choice if you are traveling with your macaron, as the paper bag they give you otherwise provides absolutely no protection. After I had paid, I was offered a free raspberry marshmallow macaron to try, as it was a new flavor that they were trying to promote. I accepted it from the silver platter upon which it was offered to me (by a man in a suit wearing white satin gloves, no less), and ate it as I walked down the street to the metro. It was overly sweet and the flavor was one note. I could sense the marshmallow from the filling, but the raspberry flavor was lacking, and I felt like it needed some acid or salt to balance out the cloying sweetness. It did, however, have a lovely texture; the shell was airy with a crisp exterior that gave way to a soft interior that had just the slightest bit of chew before giving away to a melt-in-your-mouth kind of "crumb" that is very distinct to a well-made macaron.
The flavors I bought to try (pictured above, on the left) were salted caramel, pistachio, cherry, and fleur d'oranger (orange flower blossom). I took them home and split them that night with B. for dessert after dinner. The salted caramel was good, sweet, but balanced and very well flavored. The pistachio wasn't quite as strongly perfumed, but it was enjoyable. I didn't get as much of a cherry or orange blossom flavor, respectively, from the last two macarons, but they were both pleasant to eat, albeit a little on the sweet side. B. and I agreed that the macarons at Ladurée were good, although more delicate flavors weren't captured as well as strong flavors were.
At Pierre Hermé, I also bought several macarons. Here, they charge for the macarons per piece until you buy more than four; then they charge you by weight. The flavors here were more unique; I suppose Pierre Hermé finds single-flavored macarons to be too easy, and he's a man who likes more of a challenge.
At the top left is the "Eden", a macaron that combines saffron, peach, and apricot. I was very curious and hopeful about this one, but I did not enjoy it at all. In fact, to be honest, I didn't even want to swallow the bite that I took, that was how unpleasant I found it, and I am not one who normally disdains odd flavor combinations. B. agreed with me that it was not good. In the middle on the top row is the "Mosaic" macaron, which features a vanilla macaron and pistachio filling flavored with cinnamon and morello cherries. Neither of us were really crazy about this combination either. The filling had an odd and unexpected flavor of coconut, and I couldn't sense any cinnamon or pistachio. All the way to the right is the "Mogador" macaron, which features milk chocolate and passionfruit. I thought this was the best one. Both flavors were strong and they worked together well. Unlike the other macarons, in which the flavors had seemed to be fighting with each other, these flavors were complimentary. On the bottom left is "infiniment caramel" which features salted caramel (fleur de sel). This was good. It was much heavier on the salt than the salted caramel macaron at Ladurée. Though I preferred this version, B. preferred the one at Ladurée. Lastly, the pale macaron on the bottom was "infiniment jasmine", which was supposed to have flavors of jasmine flower and jasmine tea, but they did not come through in the macaron.
I was very disappointed by Pierre Hermé after this tasting, and B. told me that we should have ended the taste test with Ladurée to finish on a good note, since neither of us particularly enjoyed the lingering tastes we had in our mouths of the macarons from PH.
I also compared the two versions of the Ispahan. This raspberry macaron with a rose-lychee filling is originally a creation of Pierre Hermé. Ladurée (on the right/on top) sells it for 7€20; Pierre Hermé sells it for 6€90 (left/lower image with the "PH" sticker).
Though they look almost identical, B. and I agreed that Ladurée makes the better version of the Ispahan (pictured on top); their re-creation is preferable to the original. Their macaron shell was texturally better and their filling was more flavorful. Pierre Hermé's version was good (better than his other macarons), but the macaron shell was not well made. It was too thin and the texture was odd; the crispy shell exterior gave way to an interior that was too dry and didn't have the light crumb that I expect from a good macaron (pictured on bottom). The filling was also too sweet and didn't have enough flavor, though large pieces of lychee were generously mixed in. While the flavor combination in both cases was good, Ladurée had better execution.
It saddened me greatly to see Pierre Hermé fail so terribly in comparison as I had expected it to be a closer call, but now I can say with no hesitation that if I had to pick, Ladurée is my preference. I can see why people are always lining up in Paris and NYC to buy the sweet creations.
Though Ladurée has many locations worldwide, if you find yourself in Paris, my recommendation is to go to the one on 21 rue Bonaparte as it is not as crowded as some of the other locations (the one near Madeleine often has a very long line, since it is in an area frequented by tourists) and it still has a salon if you want to sit down for tea or food. For NYC locals, there is a store at 864 Madison Avenue, however from what I've heard, there is always a line.
Finally, one last word of advice: take care when traveling with macarons. They smush rather easily.
I first went to Ladurée when I was thirteen. This was many years ago, before the name was well-known in the States. It was a place that my parents had read about and they decided to take their two daughters there. We sat down in the salon and oohed and aaahed over everything as we ate the pastries and drank the tea. It was wonderful. The service was friendly and attentive and everything was delicious, but I haven't been back since. Ladurée is good, but pastries everywhere in Paris are good, and I never really got into the macaron food fad that everyone else seems to be following. Sure, I enjoy the delicate little rounds, but I'd rather have some good foie gras.
Recently, however, when my boyfriend came to visit, he brought two boxes of macarons for my family from Ladurée, sweetly packed and carried across the ocean for us. My sister and my parents were touched by his gesture, and it piqued my interest in going back to the shop.
Ladurée, which was founded back in 1862 (a fact that is printed on almost everything that bears their name, so I think they're rather proud of it), is often credited as being the first place in which the modern-day macaron was made. The modern-day macaron I speak of is a tiny "cake" (if one can even use that word) made of egg whites, almond flour, and sugar baked into small airy rounds that are smooth, crisp, and soft all at once. Two of these small "shells" are joined together by a ganache or jelly-like filling in the middle. Flavors can range from raspberry and chocolate to olive oil or thyme.
I first visited Pierre Hermé two summers ago. I had heard much about it for years before then, but I just hadn't taken the time to visit. Pierre Hermé (the man) is famous in the gourmet pastry scene for his bold, sometimes risky, flavor pairings, including the very famous Ispahan, a macaron that combines raspberry, lychee, and rose together so successfully that it has been copied everywhere, including at Ladurée.
My sister and I went there together, and we didn't try any of the macarons (again, I was never big into the macaron craze), but we bought the Ispahan and a dark chocolate mousse pastry. I remember that the Ispahan was good, but I don't recall being blown away by it.
But I am no longer eighteen and it has been a long time since I was thirteen, and so I had to go back. I wanted to do a taste test between the two places and to compare the macarons at Pierre Hermé with those at Ladurée.
At Ladurée I bought several macarons, for 1€70 a piece. Boxes are more expensive, but are a good choice if you are traveling with your macaron, as the paper bag they give you otherwise provides absolutely no protection. After I had paid, I was offered a free raspberry marshmallow macaron to try, as it was a new flavor that they were trying to promote. I accepted it from the silver platter upon which it was offered to me (by a man in a suit wearing white satin gloves, no less), and ate it as I walked down the street to the metro. It was overly sweet and the flavor was one note. I could sense the marshmallow from the filling, but the raspberry flavor was lacking, and I felt like it needed some acid or salt to balance out the cloying sweetness. It did, however, have a lovely texture; the shell was airy with a crisp exterior that gave way to a soft interior that had just the slightest bit of chew before giving away to a melt-in-your-mouth kind of "crumb" that is very distinct to a well-made macaron.
The flavors I bought to try (pictured above, on the left) were salted caramel, pistachio, cherry, and fleur d'oranger (orange flower blossom). I took them home and split them that night with B. for dessert after dinner. The salted caramel was good, sweet, but balanced and very well flavored. The pistachio wasn't quite as strongly perfumed, but it was enjoyable. I didn't get as much of a cherry or orange blossom flavor, respectively, from the last two macarons, but they were both pleasant to eat, albeit a little on the sweet side. B. and I agreed that the macarons at Ladurée were good, although more delicate flavors weren't captured as well as strong flavors were.
At Pierre Hermé, I also bought several macarons. Here, they charge for the macarons per piece until you buy more than four; then they charge you by weight. The flavors here were more unique; I suppose Pierre Hermé finds single-flavored macarons to be too easy, and he's a man who likes more of a challenge.
At the top left is the "Eden", a macaron that combines saffron, peach, and apricot. I was very curious and hopeful about this one, but I did not enjoy it at all. In fact, to be honest, I didn't even want to swallow the bite that I took, that was how unpleasant I found it, and I am not one who normally disdains odd flavor combinations. B. agreed with me that it was not good. In the middle on the top row is the "Mosaic" macaron, which features a vanilla macaron and pistachio filling flavored with cinnamon and morello cherries. Neither of us were really crazy about this combination either. The filling had an odd and unexpected flavor of coconut, and I couldn't sense any cinnamon or pistachio. All the way to the right is the "Mogador" macaron, which features milk chocolate and passionfruit. I thought this was the best one. Both flavors were strong and they worked together well. Unlike the other macarons, in which the flavors had seemed to be fighting with each other, these flavors were complimentary. On the bottom left is "infiniment caramel" which features salted caramel (fleur de sel). This was good. It was much heavier on the salt than the salted caramel macaron at Ladurée. Though I preferred this version, B. preferred the one at Ladurée. Lastly, the pale macaron on the bottom was "infiniment jasmine", which was supposed to have flavors of jasmine flower and jasmine tea, but they did not come through in the macaron.
I was very disappointed by Pierre Hermé after this tasting, and B. told me that we should have ended the taste test with Ladurée to finish on a good note, since neither of us particularly enjoyed the lingering tastes we had in our mouths of the macarons from PH.
I also compared the two versions of the Ispahan. This raspberry macaron with a rose-lychee filling is originally a creation of Pierre Hermé. Ladurée (on the right/on top) sells it for 7€20; Pierre Hermé sells it for 6€90 (left/lower image with the "PH" sticker).
Though they look almost identical, B. and I agreed that Ladurée makes the better version of the Ispahan (pictured on top); their re-creation is preferable to the original. Their macaron shell was texturally better and their filling was more flavorful. Pierre Hermé's version was good (better than his other macarons), but the macaron shell was not well made. It was too thin and the texture was odd; the crispy shell exterior gave way to an interior that was too dry and didn't have the light crumb that I expect from a good macaron (pictured on bottom). The filling was also too sweet and didn't have enough flavor, though large pieces of lychee were generously mixed in. While the flavor combination in both cases was good, Ladurée had better execution.
It saddened me greatly to see Pierre Hermé fail so terribly in comparison as I had expected it to be a closer call, but now I can say with no hesitation that if I had to pick, Ladurée is my preference. I can see why people are always lining up in Paris and NYC to buy the sweet creations.
Though Ladurée has many locations worldwide, if you find yourself in Paris, my recommendation is to go to the one on 21 rue Bonaparte as it is not as crowded as some of the other locations (the one near Madeleine often has a very long line, since it is in an area frequented by tourists) and it still has a salon if you want to sit down for tea or food. For NYC locals, there is a store at 864 Madison Avenue, however from what I've heard, there is always a line.
Finally, one last word of advice: take care when traveling with macarons. They smush rather easily.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)